Talk:Siege of Tunis (Mercenary War)/GA1
GA Review
[edit]| GA toolbox |
|---|
| Reviewing |
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Reviewer: Hog Farm (talk · contribs) 14:13, 27 October 2020 (UTC)
- Lead
- "They were tortured, mutilated and crucified still living." - Should it be while still living?
- It could be. Done.
- The aftermath section isn't really summarized in the lead
- True. Added a bit.
- War
- I find it a bit odd that "Mercenary War" is not linked or mentioned in the body proper, just in the title, lead, infobox, and a caption. My recommendation might be to replace the complicated further reading section hatnote under the war section with a simpler one just to Mercenary War. You do mention it as the Truceless War after the Naravas battle, but I'd still recommend stating directly when the fighting started what they called the war
- You are quite right. Added a bit about it at the point where the pay dispute turned into a war, and added a hat note to the top of that section.
- Note 1 probably needs a citation. The patrilineal relationship of Carthaginian leaders isn't quite to the "the sky is blue" level of knowledge.
- Oops. Must have stopped checking at the end of the text! Added.
- "At some point between March and September 239 BC the previously loyal cities of Utica and Hippo slew their Carthaginian garrisons and joined the rebels." - Do we know why?
- No. Nothing at all. I could OR, but it would be complete speculation.
- Opposing armies
- "Roman sources refer to these foreign fighters derogatively as "mercenaries", but Goldsworthy describes to this as "a gross oversimplification"" - Who's Goldsworthy? I've read enough of these articles to know who he is, but the average reader won't
- I thought that he was already introduced. I too have clearly done too many of these. Fixed.
- Link Balearic Islands
- Done.
- Siege
- "Hamilcar then travelled to the northern camp with the ten captured rebel leaders" - The bit about the Saw doesn't directly state that it was ten captured rebel leaders there, so the reader is forced to make a conjecture, which I'd recommend just stating directly.
- Well I already have "Eventually, the surrounded troops forced their leaders, including Spendius, to parley with Hamilcar, but on a thin pretext he took them prisoner." but a bit added to clarify for readers.
Tidy work here. That's about all I can find in my GA reviewing mode (I mentally approach different levels of reviews with different mindsets, which look for different things).
- I struggle a bit to do that, although I try not to apply FAC expectations to GANs.
Hog Farm Bacon 01:31, 28 October 2020 (UTC)
- Cheers Hog Farm, that is great responses above. If you fancy tackling the prequel, Battle of the Saw it has recently been GANed. Gog the Mild (talk) 12:30, 28 October 2020 (UTC)