Talk:Kalipada Singha Thakur

Self publish source

Hi.I have gone through your message. I am the grandson of Late Raja Kalipada Singha Thakur. I am writing the history from our family tree as well as from some reliable written documents. How can you edit that Kalipada Singha Thakud had one son? While actually he had four sons and three daughters.(Jyoti Prasad Singha Thakur (talk) 19:39, 28 January 2016 (UTC))

Hi @Jyoti Prasad Singha Thakur:, first you read Wikipedia rules already drop a Welcome note in your talk page. In sort don't add anything without reliable Source, feel free to add back with a reliable Source --Bongan^® →TalkToMe← 08:49, 29 January 2016 (UTC)

Hi@Bongan:,at first read the sources and references mentioned on the page,Dasgupta, Gautam Kumar; Biswas, Samira,; Mallik, Rabiranjan, (2009), Heritage Tourism: An Anthropological Journey to Bishnupur, A Mittal Publication, p. 21, ISBN 8183242944. Chandra, Manoranjan (2004), "Mallabhum Bishnupur", Digital Library of India (Barcode 99999990343523) (Kolkata. Deys Publishing), ISBN 8183242944, it is mentioned on the both sources, Kalipada Singha Thakur had four sons and three daughters, names of the four sons are clearly mentioned. Also the history edited by me about Kalipada Singha Thakur are also mentioned in the second source i.e."Mallabhum Bishnupur", Digital Library of India (Barcode 99999990343523) (Kolkata. Deys Publishing), ISBN 8183242944. With out reading the sources, how can you blame me by saying"...don't add anything without reliable Source"? Please read those sources at first then advise me or threaten me to block from Wikipedia.(Jyoti Prasad Singha Thakur (talk) 11:00, 29 January 2016 (UTC))

1. jyoti you already commented you are writing the history from your family tree as well as from some reliable written documents. 2. ref. Dasgupta pg 21 Kalipada Singha Thakur missing in ref. Kalipada Singha Thakur mention only two pages are 42 and 43. 3. Yes I agree Singha Thakur had four sons youngest son Salil Kumar Singha Thakur ref. Dasgupta pg 43 its already added by me. 4.Ref. Chandra, Manoranjan Digital Library of India (Barcode 99999990343523) but you deleted ref link two times without reason 1, 2 and try to add 3 times poor and self ref. TOI, rajput ?. 5. I am already giving you reason, msg and warning but you not reply and undo it.1, 2, 3, 4 6. I think you add own article and add all ref. to show like Hoax. May be some are correct. If i am wrong then correct me. 7. why u add all unrelated contain already add in Mallabhum different king pages. 8. your work not constructive 1 2 etc. you are adding ref. on top of the page see this add ref in line & remember discuss on talk page not user page 1. 9. you say (it is mentioned on the both sources) but you forget to mention page no. pls see this for future good constructive work Help:Referencing for beginners and read all the wiki links which are drop in your talk page by other users . 10. yes I read the ref. and contribute all Mallabhum king pages. --Bongan^® →TalkToMe← 19:06, 29 January 2016 (UTC)

Hi@Bongan:,1.It is true, that I am new in wikipedia. That is why some syntax error is committed by me unintentionally.

2.But the history modified by me , is based upon facts and references not only from my family tree or other documents. 3.You have again edited from my modification which is baseless, because: a.Raja Kalipada Singha Thakur is the grand son of Raja Ramkrishna Singha Dev and Rani Prasanna Kumari Devi(2nd wife)(Ref. Chandra, Manoranjan, Mallabhum Bishnupur)Page 238). You have copied from the book of Dasgupta, where again it is clearly mentioned that source of Dasgupta's book is Chandra Monoranjan (Page 43). 3.You have repeatedly edit my modification that Kalipada Singha Thakur had 4 sons. But atlast you have agreed with my words. 4. Last, but not least, I am again editing your modification,mentioning page nos. of the references, may be some syntax error are till exists, please try to correct those errors, if possible, but don't try to edit the main texts, as it is genuine and with real facts.

11.@Jyoti Prasad Singha Thakur: you just Copy paste previous ver article.

12. You not read my points and repeating same mistake.

13. Misused of Dasgupta p 43 source. Why you added this source to all artice?(see below point 17)

a. Mention in Dasgupta ref.(Kalipada Singha Thakur had 4 sons only 1 name Mention Salil Kumar Singha Thakur) b. Not Mention in Dasgupta ref. (Kalipada Singha Thakur other 3 sons Name), How many wives & How many daughters

14. Don't add unrelated contain already added in Mallabhum different king pages (see above point no.7). next time use links

15. Don't add poor and self ref. source TOI, rajput(see above point no.4)

16. New user Please go through Wikipedia training before making any more edits.

17. you say Kalipada Singha Thakur is the grand son of Ramkrishna Singha Dev where again it is clearly mentioned that source of Dasgupta's book Page 43. (Good ref. with wrong pg. no. pls see Who is Kalipada Singha Thakur section.)--Bongan^® →TalkToMe← 11:09, 12 March 2016 (UTC)

Who is Kalipada Singha Thakur

There are 3 Different opinion.

1. kalipada Singha Thakur the grand son (from daughter's side) of Ramkishor Singha Dev(Hikim saheb) ref. Dasgupta p 42- 43 & 30

2. kalipada Singha Thakur was the daughter's son of prasannya moyee devi wife of Ramkrishna Singha Dev ref. Dasgupta p 31 & Chandra p=238

3. kalipada Singha Thakur was the daughter's son of prasannya moyee devi - the second wife of Nilmoni Singha Dev ref. Dasgupta p 42- 43

@Jyoti Prasad Singha Thakur: just added another opinion but why you vandalized other opinion with good ref. ?. If you try to add other scholars Opinion than welcome, but existing referenced opinion should not the tampered and vandalized. When multiple sources give different opinions, we must mention all of them as per WP:WEIGHT. You are not allowed to use your own original research --Bongan^® →TalkToMe← 11:14, 12 March 2016 (UTC)