Milestone-Based Fusion Development Program
The Milestone-Based Fusion Development Program is an ongoing program under the United States Department of Energy, office of fusion energy sciences to support the development of a fusion pilot plant (FPP) and eventually commercialize fusion power.[1][2][3] As of 2024, eight private companies have received a total of $46 million for the first 18-month period of performance. The program is planned to run for five years and culminate in one or more fusion pilot plants.
History
[edit]The need for a fusion pilot plant has been recognized throughout the program to develop fusion power. Most recently before the announcement of the Milestone-Based Fusion Development Program, in 2021 the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM) released a report which highlighted the need for such a program and advised its creation.[4] In 2022 the Biden administration and DOE announced a Bold Decadal Vision for Commercial Fusion Energy which included plans to fund support for pilot plant development program.[5][6][7]
The funding opportunity announcement (FOA) was announced by the US Department of Energy in September 2022, and $50 million was earmarked for the program.[8][9] Applications were received in December 2022.[3][10] Eight companies were selected for negotiation in May 2023. However, agreements were not signed with the awardees until more than a year later in June 2024,[11] reportedly due to concerns over how intellectual property would be handled.[12]
In June 2024, at a White House summit the Department of Energy announced that all eight companies had successfully concluded detailed milestones negotiations with the federal government and that agreements had been signed to commence the Milestone Program.[13]
Awardees
[edit]The eight awardees are:
- Commonwealth Fusion Systems (Cambridge, MA)
- Focused Energy Inc. (Austin, TX)
- Thea Energy, Inc (formerly Princeton Stellarators Inc., Branchburg, NJ)
- Realta Fusion Inc. (Madison, WI)
- Tokamak Energy Inc. (US subsidiary of UK-based company, Bruceton Mills, WV)
- Type One Energy Group (Madison, WI)
- Xcimer Energy Inc. (Redwood City, CA)
- Zap Energy Inc. (Everett, WA)
The awardees include 2 companies pursuing the tokamak approach, 2 companies pursuing the stellarator approach, 2 companies pursuing inertial confinement fusion, one company pursuing the magnetic mirror approach, and one company pursuing the Z-pinch approach.
Structure
[edit]The program is structured as a public–private partnership between the DOE and the awardees. The companies unlock matching funds upon completion of quantitative milestones, up to the full award amount.[10]
The program is structured in three periods of performance: One spanning the first 18 months, one spanning the second 18 months, and one spanning the remaining 24 months of the five-year term. The first period of performance will presumably end around the end of 2025, assuming a start date based on the June 2024 announcement.
Only the first period of performance has been announced and awarded. The $46 million number is for the first period of performance. Subsequent periods of performance have not as of 2024 been announced, appropriated, or awarded.
The applicants were encouraged to propose collaborations with US national laboratories, with which the DOE would contract separately and pay directly. Oak Ridge National Laboratory will work with six of the eight companies.[14]
Dispute over intellectual property
[edit]The year-long gap between the announcement of awardees and their signing agreements with the DOE was apparently due to a dispute over how companies' intellectual property would be treated under the award.[12] Reporting stated that the companies' rights to existing and subject intellectual property was not sufficiently safeguarded under the DOE's initial proposed terms. At the time of the announcement, the total private investment in Commonwealth Fusion Systems was larger than $2 billion.
Awardee table
[edit]| Company name | Location | Approach | Amount awarded in first period of performance | Project name[14] |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commonwealth Fusion Systems | Cambridge MA | Tokamak | $15 million[15] | Commercial fusion power on a decadal timescale with the compact, high-field ARC power plant |
| Focused energy Inc | Austin TX | Inertial confinement fusion | Company has not announced | ? |
| Thea Energy, Inc (formerly Princeton Stellarators Inc) | Branchburg NJ | Stellarator | Company has not announced | Stellarator fusion pilot plant enabled by array of planar shaping coils |
| Realta Fusion Inc | Madison WI | Magnetic mirror | Company has not announced | The high-field axisymmetric mirror on a faster path to fusion energy |
| Tokamak Energy (US subsidiary of UK company) | Bruceton Mills WV | Spherical tokamak | Company has not announced | ST-E1 preliminary design review for a fusion pilot plant |
| Type One Energy Group | Madison WI | Stellarator | Company has not announced | The high-field stellarator path to commercial fusion energy |
| Xcimer Energy Inc. | Redwood City, CA | Inertial confinement fusion | $9 million[16] | IFE pilot plant with a low-cost, high-energy excimer driver and the HYLIFE concept |
| Zap Energy Inc. | Everett, WA | Z-pinch | $5 million[17] | ? |
References
[edit]- ^ "DOE Announces $46 Million for Commercial Fusion Energy Development". Energy.gov. Retrieved 2024-07-05.
- ^ "U.S. fusion pilot program ready to back designs from industry-led teams". www.ans.org. Retrieved 2024-07-05.
- ^ a b "Department of Energy Announces $50 Million for a Milestone-Based Fusion Development Program". Energy.gov. Retrieved 2024-07-05.
- ^ Bringing Fusion to the U.S. Grid. Committee on the Key Goals and Innovation Needed for a U.S. Fusion Pilot Plant, Board on Physics and Astronomy, Board on Energy and Environmental Systems, Nuclear and Radiation Studies Board, Division on Engineering and Physical Sciences, Division on Earth and Life Studies, National Academy of Engineering, National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. Washington, D.C.: National Academies Press. 2021-12-16. doi:10.17226/25991. ISBN 978-0-309-68538-2.
{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: others (link) - ^ "Readout of the White House Summit on Developing a Bold Decadal Vision for Commercial Fusion Energy | OSTP". The White House. 2022-04-19. Retrieved 2024-07-05.
- ^ "Fact Sheet: Developing a Bold Vision for Commercial Fusion Energy | OSTP". The White House. 2022-03-15. Retrieved 2024-07-05.
- ^ Hsu, Scott (Feb 26, 2023). "Bold Decadal Vision for Commercial Fusion Energy, Government-University-Industry Research Roundtable Webinar: Unlocking New Possibilities for Commercial Fusion National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine". Retrieved July 5, 2024.
- ^ "U.S. fusion pilot program ready to back designs from industry-led teams". Nuclear newswire. American Nuclear Society. September 27, 2022.
- ^ Department of Energy Announces $50 Million for a Milestone-Based Fusion Development Program (press release), United States Department of Energy Office of Science, September 22, 2022
- ^ a b "OSTI FOA number DE-FOA-0002809" (PDF). September 22, 2022.
- ^ "DOE Announces New Decadal Fusion Energy Strategy". Energy.gov. Retrieved 2024-07-05.
- ^ a b Behr, Peter (2024-02-27). "Intellectual property fights hobble DOE fusion program". E&E News by POLITICO. Retrieved 2024-07-05.
- ^ "DOE Announces New Decadal Fusion Energy Strategy". Energy.gov. Retrieved 2024-06-26.
- ^ a b "ORNL to be involved in multiple DOE-funded commercial fusion energy development projects | ORNL". www.ornl.gov. June 2023. Retrieved 2024-07-05.
- ^ "Commonwealth Fusion Systems Signs $15 Million DOE Agreement To Advance Commercial Fusion Energy". cfs.energy. Retrieved 2024-07-05.
- ^ "Xcimer Energy Announces $9 Million US Department of Energy Award to Develop Laser-Driven Inertial Fusion Energy". May 31, 2023.
- ^ "DOE award to Zap Energy for fusion pilot plant design". www.zapenergy.com. Retrieved 2024-07-05.