Wikipedia:Discussion review
 | This is a failed proposal. Consensus for its implementation was not established within a reasonable period of time. If you want to revive discussion, please use the talk page or initiate a thread at the village pump. |
Discussion review is a process that reviews contested closures of discussions to determine if the close was a reasonable interpretation of community consensus. Before listing a discussion here, an attempt should be made to resolve the issue through discussion with the closer. If that is unsuccessful, you may request list the discussion and request review here. Before requesting review, understand that review should not be used as an opportunity to reargue the underlying dispute, it is only intended for use when there is a problem with the closure itself. This process does not apply to closure reviews covered by other venues (e.g. Wikipedia:Deletion review and Wikipedia:Move review), Arbitration Committee decisions, or bureaucrat discussions. It also does not apply to discussions that are not formally closed.
Choices
[edit]- Endorse decision.
- Overturn... decision. And then...
- Relist discussion.
- Change to no consensus.
- Change to <whatever decision it should be>.
- Move to another venue.
- Start another discussion.