Jump to content

Substantial meal

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

An example of a pub meal

A substantial meal or table meal is a legal term of art regarding the application of alcohol licensing laws in England and Wales. The purported definition of "substantial meal" generated significant press discussion during the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic in spite of the fact that the English COVID-19 regulations made no use of the expression, instead referring to "main meal" and later to "table meal".

History

[edit]

In Soloman v Green (1955), the High Court held that sandwiches and sausages on sticks amounted to a meal under English and Welsh law.[1] The Licensing Act 1964 defined "table service" as "a meal eaten by a person seated at a table, or at a counter or other structure that serves the purpose of a table and is not used for the service of refreshments for consumption by persons not seated at a table or structure serving the purpose of a table".[2]

In Timmis v Millman (1965), where Millman and Yarnold had been consuming light ale and stout outside of permitted hours (but within the supper hour extension of the time), the High Court found the sandwiches the pair were eating constituted a "table meal" as they "were so substantial, and assisted by the pickles and beetroot so as to justify that it was a table meal and not a mere snack from the bar".[3][4] The Licensing Act 2003 contains a clause which permits 16- or 17-year-olds to consume beer, wine or cider with a table meal if they are accompanied by an adult.[4]

The terms "table meals", "substantial meals", "plated meals" and "substantial food" are considered analogous terms in a sample of 319 "statements of licensing policy" issued by local authorities (a document which details how they approach licensing applications in their area). Of the sampled documents, 95 made reference to one of these terms and a further 13 to alcohol being "ancillary to food" or a meal.[5]

The terms have been criticised as subjective, and their application has been seen as being affected by snobbery. Research has shown that questions of "class and calibre" form part of the interpretation and enforcement of licensing conditions.[5] For example, "high-end crisps" served in "substantial portions accompanied with various elaborate dips" were considered a substantial meal in a 2017 Westminster City Council hearing, with the council congratulating the owner on "[creating] a 'non-Walkers' crisp offer and the desire to celebrate the great British potato at its peak and most hip".[5]

COVID tier restrictions in England

[edit]

During the October–November 2020 first COVID-19 tier regulations in England, pubs and restaurants in tier 3 areas were permitted to serve alcoholic drinks only with a "main meal". This was defined as being a meal at least equivalent to the main course of a main midday or evening meal.[6] Summarising the effect of the regulations, Health Secretary Matt Hancock told Parliament that "pubs and bars must close unless operating as restaurants".[7]

After the second lockdown, the all-tier regulations that came into force in December 2020 re-introduced a similar restriction but replaced the wording "main meal" with "table meal", that being defined as a meal at least equivalent to breakfast or the main course of a midday or evening meal.[8]

Although in neither case did the legal regulations use the term "substantial meal", the government's COVID-19 Winter Plan stated "In tier 2, pubs and bars must close unless they are serving substantial meals (like a full breakfast, main lunchtime or evening meal), along with accompanying drinks."[9] This restriction was reported to have had a significant impact on pubs that were led by alcohol sales ('wet-led' pubs).[5]

In spite of the fact that the regulations made no use of the term, the press showed substantial interest in the definition of "substantial meal". In Manchester, 22-inch slices of pizza were argued to have been substantial after police initially shut down one bar for serving them alongside alcohol.[10] Although ministers had no legal authority to define a "substantial meal", definitions offered by various politicians included one "you would expect to have as a midday meal or an evening meal", disregarding snacks such as crisps and chips; but not a Cornish pasty on its own, the PM's spokesman insisting that "bar snacks do not count".[11]

Newspapers published articles on whether a scotch egg constituted a substantial meal.[12] On 30 November 2020, the Environment and Food Secretary George Eustice stated that they "probably would count".[11][13] According to Cabinet Office Minister Michael Gove,[14][15][12][13] scotch eggs could not serve as substantial meal, but the Health Secretary Matt Hancock said: "A scotch egg that is served as a substantial meal, that is a substantial meal."[16]

In March 2021, the High Court granted judicial review of the "substantial meal" [sic] aspect of the regulations on the basis that it was arguably discriminatory towards people of non-White or BAME backgrounds who disproportionally relied on wet-led pubs and who could not afford substantial meals out. The case did not ultimately proceed to trial after the regulations were revoked.[17]

COVID restrictions in Ireland

[edit]

In Ireland, on 29 June 2020, restaurants and cafés providing on-premises food and drink could re-open subject to social distancing measures and strict cleaning requirements. Bars and pubs offering table service only were permitted to re-open provided that customers bought a "substantial" meal costing at least €9.[18][19]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ "Licensing update -- the future of regulation of children in bars proposed by the children's certificate in the Deregulation and Contracting Out Bill". Law Gazette. 11 May 1994. Retrieved 6 December 2020.
  2. ^ Wright, Chris (27 November 2020). "Substantial Meal and Pubs". Pubs Advisory Service. Retrieved 6 December 2020.
  3. ^ "A substantial meal? Try pickles and beetroot to stay legal". Law Gazette. 13 October 2020. Retrieved 6 December 2020.
  4. ^ a b Tolhurst, Alain (1 December 2020). "Everything You Need To Know About #ScotchEggGate And 'Substantial Meals'". Politics Home. Retrieved 6 December 2020.
  5. ^ a b c d Meers, Jed (3 December 2020). "Is a Scotch egg a meal? I investigated more than 300 council rulings to find out". The Conversation. Retrieved 6 December 2020.
  6. ^ "SI 1105". Legislation.gov.uk. 14 October 2020. The Health Protection (Coronavirus, Local COVID-19 Alert Level) (Very High) (England) Regulations 2020. Retrieved 15 August 2023. Schedule 1, para 16
  7. ^ Hancock, Matt (26 November 2020). "Covid-19 Update: Statement made on 26 November 2020". Hansard. UK Parliament.
  8. ^ "SI 1374". Legislation.gov.uk. 2 December 2020. The Health Protection (Coronavirus, Restrictions) (All Tiers) (England) Regulations 2020. Retrieved 1 December 2020. Schedule 1, para 14(1)–(4)
  9. ^ "COVID-19 Winter Plan". Cabinet Office. 2 December 2020. Retrieved 6 December 2020 – via GOV.UK.
  10. ^ Wilkinson, Damon (25 October 2020). "Massive slices of pizza back on menu at NQ bar after Tier 3 rules confusion". Manchester Evening News. Retrieved 6 December 2020.
  11. ^ a b Coles, Amy (2 December 2020). "COVID-19: What is a substantial meal? No 10 overrules food minister as pubs brace for tier change". Sky News. Retrieved 6 December 2020.
  12. ^ a b Rear, Jack (1 December 2020). "Is a scotch egg really a substantial meal? The nutrition experts weigh in". Telegraph Media Group Limited.
  13. ^ a b Yorke, Harry (30 November 2020). "Scotch egg counts as 'substantial meal' in Tier 2, says minister". Telegraph Media Group Limited.
  14. ^ Ferguson, Donna (6 December 2020). "Making a meal out of it: scotch egg sales soar in tier 2". The Observer. Retrieved 6 December 2020.
  15. ^ Sheridan, Danielle (1 December 2020). "Scotch Egg row deepens after Michael Gove suggests food was merely a starter". Telegraph Media Group Limited.
  16. ^ Murphy, Joe (2 December 2020). "Third minister gives scrambled answer over scotch eggs". Evening Standard. Retrieved 7 December 2020.
  17. ^ "Substantial meal policy may have discriminated against BAME customers in pubs, High Court rules". Telegraph. 1 March 2021.
  18. ^ "At a glance: what Covid-19 roadmap looks like as restrictions eased". RTÉ News and Current Affairs. 19 June 2020. Retrieved 19 June 2020.
  19. ^ "Pubs can only reopen if a 'substantial' meal costs at least €9". RTÉ News and Current Affairs. 16 June 2020. Retrieved 29 June 2020.
Retrieved from "http://en.wiki.x.io/w/index.php?title=Substantial_meal&oldid=1259523411"