Jump to content

Melville Monument

Coordinates: 55°57′15″N 3°11′35″W / 55.95423°N 3.19315°W / 55.95423; -3.19315
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Richard Nevell (talk | contribs) at 14:11, 7 November 2020 (→Controversy over Dundas and the abolition movement: remove as a copyright violation. This was taken verbatim from Davis (1999), and while a reference was given it was not indicated that this was not paraphrased.). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

The Melville Monument is a 150-foot high monumental column. One of the most prominent memorials in Edinburgh, it commemorates Henry Dundas, 1st Viscount Melville, whose statue surmounts the column.

The Category A listed column dominates St Andrew Square, in the heart of the New Town which Dundas helped to establish. It was erected in 1821, 14 years after his death. The architect was William Burn. The statue was added in 1828. The plaque at the base of the statue says the monument was paid for by officers and men of the Royal Navy.

Conservation

In 2008 the Melville Monument was restored as part of the Twelve Monuments Project, a joint initiative of Edinburgh World Heritage and the City of Edinburgh Council.[1]

Controversy over Dundas and the abolition movement

On June 7, 2020, during a Black Lives Matter protest, the Melville Monument was graffitied. Demonstrators believed Dundas had caused a 15-year-delay in Parliament voting to abolish the slave trade.[2]

The leading proponent of the movement to denounce Henry Dundas is Sir Geoff Palmer, a human rights activist and retired science professor at Heriot-Watt University in Edinburgh. He argues that because Henry Dundas proposed an amendment to a motion before the House of Commons in 1792 to achieve abolition gradually, rather than immediately, he delayed abolition of the slave trade by 15 years.[3]

His interpretation of events is contested by at least two historians - Brian Young of Oxford University and Michael Fry, biographer of Henry Dundas. They note that the motion to abolish slavery was heading for certain defeat in the House of Commons until Dundas proposed the amendment for gradual abolition, to be achieved by 1800, but that after the successful vote in the House of Commons the House of Lords declined to consider the matter. In August 2020 Edinburgh World Heritage and Essential Edinburgh applied for planning to erect a plaque on the Pillar. Descendant of Henry Dundas slams this as ‘biased’, ‘defamatory’ and ‘historically inaccurate’. [4]

However, other historians such as Diana Paton and Stephen Tomkins argue that Dundas was privately opposed to abolition of the slave trade.[5][6][7] They maintain that when Dundas inserted the word "gradual" into the debate, he in effect postponed the discussion on the slave trade until an unspecified date in the future, and subverted the abolitionist movement.[8][9] Between 1792 and 1807, when the slave trade was eventually abolished, another half a million Africans were transported into slavery in the British colonies. These historians point out that slavery did not end gradually, but it took another vote in 1807 to finally bring the trade to an end.[10][11][12] In 1795, the poet and anti-slavery campaigner Samuel Taylor Coleridge observed that the Bill "passed the House of Commons mangled and mutilated by the amendments of Mr Dundas, and it has been dying ever since of a slow decline in the House of Lords.(Coleridge must have missed the debate in the House of Commons on the Abolition of the Slave Trade on 26th February 1793.)[13][14] Dundas insisted that any abolition of the slave trade would have to be dependent on the support of West Indian colonial legislatures, and the implementation of laws concerning the amelioration of the conditions of slaves. Abolitionists argued correctly that West Indian assemblies would never support such measures, and that by making the abolition of the slave trade dependent on colonial reforms, Dundas was in effect indefinitely delaying it.[15]

As a lawyer, Dundas also won a landmark case in the abolition of slavery in Scotland. In 1777 in Knight v Wedderburn, he represented a slave who had been brought to Scotland, and who wanted to be freed. He successfully appealed Knight's case, twice, ultimately achieving a victory against slavery when Scotland's highest court decided that no person be a slave on Scottish soil. The decision effectively achieved emancipation of every slave in Scotland, except for enslaved colliers and salters who had to wait until the end of the century for emancipation.[16]

In culture

Jack Docherty's short story "Statuesque", centred on this statue, was broadcast by BBC Radio 4 on 28 June 2020 in its Short Works series of stories inspired by current events.[17]

See also

List of listed buildings in Edinburgh

References

  1. ^ "The Melville Monument". Retrieved 2020-05-02.
  2. ^ BBC News (8 June 2020). "George Floyd protests: The statues being defaced". BBC. Retrieved 6 July 2020.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  3. ^ Euro News (11 June 2020). "Sir Geoff Palmer: 'Don't take down statues – take down racism'".{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  4. ^ BBC News for Edinburgh, Fife and East (14 June 2020). "Henry Dundas descendant defends ancestor's record". BBC News. Retrieved July 6, 2020.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  5. ^ "Scotland, Slavery and Statues", BBC Scotland https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000nrpb#:~:text=Scotland%2C%20Slavery%20and%20Statues%20The%20Melville%20Monument%20in,follows%20the%20debate%20over%20how%20controversial%20politician%20 Retrieved 29 October 2020.
  6. ^ Stephen Tomkins, The Clapham Sect: How Wilberforce's Circle Transformed Britain (Oxford:2010) p. 99. https://books.google.ca/books?id=3PXNBAAAQBAJ&pg=PA99&dq=Henry+Dundas+obstructed+end+slavery&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwi11YHjoPHrAhXIXM0KHXpDCRkQ6AEwAHoECAYQAg#v=onepage&q=Henry%20Dundas%20obstructed%20end%20slavery&f=false Retrieved 29 October 2020.
  7. ^ The National, "Henry Dundas: the Scotsman who kept slavery going", 10 June 2020 https://www.thenational.scot/news/18506771.henry-dundas-scotsman-kept-slavery-going/ Retrieved 29 October 2020.
  8. ^ Peter J. Kitson, Debbie Lee and Anne K. Mellor, Slavery, Abolition and Emancipation, Vol. 2 https://books.google.ca/books?id=sS_gDwAAQBAJ&pg=PT23&dq=Henry+Dundas+GRADUAL+slavery&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiklu-crPHrAhXiUd8KHUs5D8wQ6AEwA3oECAUQAg#v=onepage&q=Henry%20Dundas%20GRADUAL%20slavery&f=false Retrieved 29 October 2020.
  9. ^ National Post, "Who was Henry Dundas and why do two cities no longer want to honour his memory?" 11 June 2020 https://nationalpost.com/news/world/who-was-henry-dundas-and-why-do-two-cities-no-longer-want-to-honour-his-memory Retrieved 29 October 2020.
  10. ^ "Scotland, Slavery and Statues", BBC Scotland https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000nrpb#:~:text=Scotland%2C%20Slavery%20and%20Statues%20The%20Melville%20Monument%20in,follows%20the%20debate%20over%20how%20controversial%20politician%20 Retrieved 29 October 2020.
  11. ^ The National, "Henry Dundas: the Scotsman who kept slavery going", 10 June 2020 https://www.thenational.scot/news/18506771.henry-dundas-scotsman-kept-slavery-going/ Retrieved 29 October 2020.
  12. ^ National Post, "Who was Henry Dundas and why do two cities no longer want to honour his memory?" 11 June 2020 https://nationalpost.com/news/world/who-was-henry-dundas-and-why-do-two-cities-no-longer-want-to-honour-his-memory Retrieved 29 October 2020.
  13. ^ Peter J. Kitson, Debbie Lee and Anne K. Mellor, Slavery, Abolition and Emancipation, Vol. 2 https://books.google.ca/books?id=sS_gDwAAQBAJ&pg=PT23&dq=Henry+Dundas+GRADUAL+slavery&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiklu-crPHrAhXiUd8KHUs5D8wQ6AEwA3oECAUQAg#v=onepage&q=Henry%20Dundas%20GRADUAL%20slavery&f=false Retrieved 29 October 2020.
  14. ^ Samuel Taylor Coleridge, "Lecture on the Slave Trade", The Collected Works of Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Vol. 1: Lectures, 1795 p. 244. https://books.google.ca/books?id=D1t9BgAAQBAJ&pg=PA244&dq=Henry+Dundas+obstructed+end+slavery&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjBsIrbnfHrAhWJPM0KHcQbB2MQ6AEwAXoECAYQAg#v=onepage&q=Henry%20Dundas%20obstructed%20end%20slavery&f=false Retrieved 29 October 2020.
  15. ^ David Brion Davis, The Problem of Slavery in the Age of Revolution, 1770-1823 (Oxford: 1999) https://books.google.ca/books?id=xkAm6BKNU9MC&pg=PT112&dq=Henry+Dundas+obstructed+end+slavery&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjBsIrbnfHrAhWJPM0KHcQbB2MQ6AEwAnoECAIQAg#v=onepage&q=Henry%20Dundas%20obstructed%20end%20slavery&f=false Retrieved 29 October 2020.
  16. ^ Joseph Knight, a Negro, v John Wedderburn, Esq. [1778] Hailes 776 (15 January 1778) https://www.bailii.org/scot/cases/ScotCS/1778/Hailes020776-0472.pdf
  17. ^ "BBC Radio 4 - Short Works, Statuesque". BBC. Retrieved 28 June 2020.
Wikimedia Commons has media related to Melville Monument, Edinburgh.

55°57′15″N 3°11′35″W / 55.95423°N 3.19315°W / 55.95423; -3.19315

Retrieved from "http://en.wiki.x.io/w/index.php?title=Melville_Monument&oldid=987506908"