CES Letter
 | |
| Author | Jeremy Runnells |
|---|---|
| Language | English |
| Subject | Historical criticism of the LDS Church |
Publication date | April 2013 (version 1) October 2017 (version 2) |
| Publication place | United States |
| Pages | 84 |
| Website | cesletter |
A Letter to a CES Director, later renamed CES Letter, is an open letter critical of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church).
In 2012, Jeremy Runnells began to experience doubts over his faith. A director of institute of the LDS Church's Church Educational System (CES) asked him to write his concerns, and in response Runnells sent an 84-page letter with his concerns.[1] After not receiving a response, in April 2013 he posted his letter on the internet.[2] The letter spread throughout the Mormon blogosphere and LDS Church communities and became one of the most influential sites providing the catalyst for many people leaving the LDS Church and resigning their membership.[3][2]
The publicity from the CES Letter led Runnells to found the CES Letter Foundation, for which donations and paperback sales have allowed the CES Letter project to grow into a full-time career.[4]
Background
[edit]According to Runnells, after attending a fireside by Marlin K. Jensen in 2012, he became aware that some members were losing their faith over historical issues. After investigation, Runnells learned about and was disturbed by Joseph Smith's marriages to already-married women, and Book of Abraham historical criticisms. "I began to have these feelings of betrayal. I wasn't the village idiot. I read books—a lot of the approved books. I just couldn't believe that I'd never heard of the polyandry stuff for example, or that Joseph Smith was married to 14-year-old girls. It just really shocked me."[5]
His grandfather put him in contact with a CES institute director who suggested Runnells write a letter with a list of his concerns.[5] In March 2013, he posted a rough draft of his letter on Reddit asking for feedback.[6] In April, he shared the revised version he had sent to the CES director.[7] The letter was well-received on Reddit, with many saying they wanted to show it to friends and family.
Content
[edit]The CES Letter outlined the list of issues Runnells has with LDS Church beliefs and its historical narrative. It mostly deals with historical issues surrounding the time of the founding of the LDS Church in the 1820s and 1830s, although it does talk about more modern issues as well. This list includes issues surrounding:
- the translation and historicity of the Book of Mormon
- genetics and the Book of Mormon
- Joseph Smith's First Vision
- the Book of Abraham
- Kinderhook plates
- polygamy
- asserted prophetic abilities
- history of prophetic authority
- Mormonism and Freemasonry
- science and the Bible
- church finances
- church academics
A main theme of the letter is the belief of Runnells that the church knew unflattering aspects about its history but deliberately hid or misrepresented them.[8]
The CES Letter does not contain any new research. Runnells describes it as an condensation or distillation of preexisting research, particularly that of Jerald and Sandra Tanner.[9]
Response
[edit]No official response from the LDS Church was released, including from the CES Director to whom Runnells sent his letter. Runnells said of him, "I honestly don't blame him for not responding back to me. He was probably expecting five questions in an e-mail and I throw him close to 77-80 pages document."[5] Tad R. Callister, then general president of the church's Sunday School, referring to Runnells as an unnamed "critic", wrote that the assertions from Runnells were "rash", "partial truths", and "a classic case of 'presentism'".[10]
Numerous responses by LDS Church apologists in blogs, books, and podcasts have been made, including several by FairMormon.[11] Brian Hales of FairMormon suggested that Runnells was lying, and had been deceived by Satan. [12] Runnells posted an extensive rebuttal to FairMormon's response.[13]
FairMormon
[edit]In November 2020, FairMormon released a set of 16 videos[14] responding to Runnells, that was designed to appeal to Millennials and Generation Z. Latter Day Saint scholar Grant Hardy said of the videos, "I have found them belligerent, sarcastic, sophomoric, inaccurate, demeaning and offensive, ... In no way [do they] reflect Christian discipleship." In response to criticism that the videos were mocking Runnells and other disaffected Latter Day Saints, FairMormon chairman John Lynch said, "We are not trying to mock the people who are affected by the 'CES Letter,' ... We are mocking the letter itself and signal to people that this is a deceitful document, not to be taken seriously."[15] Runnells responded to the videos in a Facebook post, reposting a video calling them a "dishonest smear campaign".[16] In March 2021, FairMormon changed its name to FAIR, and removed the YouTube videos directed at Runnells and the CES Letter. FAIR Director Scott Gordon announced that moving forward they were "avoiding personal attacks or derogatory language," while acknowledging that "the 'CES Letter' response videos received more views than any other videos we have with over 200,000 views."[17]
Disciplinary council
[edit]In 2016, as a result of the letter's content and public criticisms of the church, Runnells' local LDS Church leaders conducted a disciplinary council to determine the membership status of Runnells. Towards the end of the council, before a determination had been made, Runnells resigned his membership, exited the church building where the council was being held, and stated to a crowd of supporters outside the church:
"I have excommunicated the LDS Church ... from my life. ... What errors or mistakes are there in the 'CES Letter' or on my website that I can publicly correct? If there are no errors or mistakes, why am I being punished for seeking and sharing the truth? I have done nothing wrong. I just wanted the truth."[18][19][20]
Utah news station KUTV pointed to a survey that 57% of LDS Church members were troubled by high-profile excommunications like Runnells, including 43% of temple recommend holders.[21]
Aftermath
[edit]The CES Letter, along with a book published by Egyptologist Robert K. Ritner and the reactions generated by apologists were influential in the 2014 release by the LDS Church of an essay addressing historical inaccuracies in the Book of Abraham.[2]
A Spider-Man comic book was published in 2018 that had a patch drawn on the protagonist that read, "CES Letter".[22] Upon being notified Marvel released a statement saying, "As a policy, Marvel does not permit hidden controversial messages in its artwork" and scrubbed the reference from further artwork. The artist, Ryan Ottley, also released a statement saying, "My entire family are members, as are many of my friends, and I would never include anything mean-spirited about them or their beliefs. The reference was in regards to a subject I am interested in and a personal decision I made in my life. It has nothing to do with the character, the story or Marvel."[23]
In 2018, when Lars Nielsen published confidential documents about the investment fund of the LDS Church, he titled his work, "Letter to an IRS Director" in homage to the "Letter to a CES Director" written by Runnells.[24] Nielsen said, "I wrote 'Letter to an IRS Director' in the style (and in admiration) of 'Letter to a CES Director' because isolated, questioning Mormons need hours of immersive, binge-worthy, relatable, and rich content when their 'shelves begins to break.'"[25]
Catalyst for members leaving the LDS Church
[edit]According to the Salt Lake Tribune and The Daily Beast, the letter has been influential in the decision of many now-former members of the LDS Church to resign their membership.[26][27][2]
Writer Jana Riess has argued that the impact of the CES Letter has been overstated, yet important. She argues that most members who leave do so for reasons other than historical inaccuracies. Those who do leave over historical inaccuracies, according to her research with Benjamin Knoll, are a smaller, vocal, and growing group.[28] This is inconsistent with a non-random, unscientific survey conducted by podcaster John Dehlin indicating that, among self-recruited survey respondents, historical reasons were a factor in 70% of former members' decisions to leave.[29]
References
[edit]- ^ Poulson, Kevin (Feb 10, 2019). "Inside the Secret Facebook War For Mormon Hearts and Minds". The Daily Beast.
- ^ a b c d Harris, M. L., Bringhurst, N. G., & Mauss, A. L. (2020). The LDS gospel topics series: A scholarly engagement. Salt Lake City, UT: Signature Books. Location 253, 6302 of 8366
- ^ Larson, Lauren (Jul 1, 2019). "The Mormon Church vs. The Internet". The Verge.
- ^ Runnells, Jeremy. "CES Letter at the Crossroads FAQs". CES Letter Foundation. Retrieved 9 March 2024.
- ^ a b c Runnells, Jeremy (June 18, 2014). "Jeremy Runnells and His Letter to a CES Director". Mormon Stories Podcast (Interview). Interviewed by John Dehlin.
- ^ Kolobot (Jeremy Runnells) (March 26, 2013). "Need Feedback! My TBM grandpa asked me to speak to his CES Director friend about my concerns. CES guy offered to talk to me. This PDF is a rough draft of what I'm sending over to both CES guy and grandpa. Need your feedback/advice, guys. Thanks!". Reddit. Archived from the original on April 25, 2016.
- ^ Kolobot (Jeremy Runnells) (April 12, 2013). "Follow-up from TBM Grandpa's CES Director friend asking me to share concerns. Final draft of letter is done! Let me know what you guys think before I send". Reddit. Archived from the original on June 24, 2015.
- ^ Ash, Michael R. (2015). Bamboozled by the 'CES Letter'. Self-Published.
- ^ Runnells, Jeremy (June 18, 2014). "CES Letter Discussed in Detail - Jeremy Runnells Pt. 2 - Mormon Stories 481". Mormon Stories Podcast (Interview). Interviewed by John Dehlin.
- ^ Callister, Tad R. (2019). A Case for the Book of Mormon. Salt Lake City, UT: Deseret Book.
- ^ Anonymous Author(s) "Response to "Letter to a CES Director: Why I Lost My Testimony (CES Letter: My Search for Answers to my Mormon Doubts) and 'Debunking FAIR's Debunking'(Debunking FairMormon)" 20 September 2019
- ^ Hales, Brian (August 4, 2014). "'There Began to be Lyings Sent Forth among the People': The Message of Jeremy Runnells". FAIR.
- ^ Runnells, Jeremy. "Debunking FairMormons Debunking". CES Letter Foundation.
- ^ "CES Letter Refutations - YouTube". YouTube.
- ^ Stack, Peggy Fletcher (Dec 12, 2020). "FairMormon's new satirical videos take on church critics, but does the humor miss the mark?". The Salt Lake Tribune.
- ^ https://www.facebook.com/runnells/posts/10158069407958737 [user-generated source]
- ^ Stack, Peggy Fletcher (March 24, 2021). "With its gentler approach, FAIR drops its snarky videos aimed at LDS Church critics". The Salt Lake Tribune.
- ^ Van Valkenburg, Nancy (April 18, 2016). "Author Jeremy Runnells Resigns From LDS Church At Excommunication Hearing In American Fork". Gephardt Daily.
- ^ Noyce, David (June 20, 2016). "Author of 'Letter to a CES Director' resigns from Mormon church". The Salt Lake Tribune.
- ^ Green, Rebecca (Apr 17, 2016). "Author of 'Letter to a CES Director' out of LDS Church after disciplinary council". Fox 13 Now.
- ^ Larry D. Curtis "Survey: Commitment of LDS Church members chilled by high-profile excommunications" KUTV 2, November 30th 2018
- ^ McMillan, Graeme (August 28, 2018). "'Spider-Man' Comic Features Reference to Anti-Mormon Book". The Hollywood Reporter.
- ^ McMillan, Graeme (August 29, 2018). "Marvel Removes Anti-Mormon Reference from 'Amazing Spider-Man' Comic". The Hollywood Reporter.
- ^ Boorstein, Michelle; Swaine, Jon (Jan 16, 2020). "These Mormon twins worked together on an IRS whistleblower complaint over the church's billions — and it tore them apart". The Washington Post.
- ^ Nielsen, Lars (18 Dec 2019). "Mormons, Here's Why I Published the Revelations About the LDS Church's $100 Billion Stockpile". Newsweek.
- ^ Stack, Peggy Fletcher (March 11, 2016). "In this new era of doubt, will a stronger Mormon faith emerge?". The Salt Lake Tribune. Archived from the original on Jan 21, 2018.
- ^ Hitt, Tarpley (May 5, 2019). "The Trials of YouTube Jesus: A Mormon Apostate Fighting for His Family". The Daily Beast.
- ^ Riess, Jana (September 19, 2019). "Jana Riess: This is your brain on Mormon Facebook". The Salt Lake Tribune.
- ^ Dehlin, John (March 2012). "Understanding Mormon Disbelief: Why do some Mormons lose their testimony, and what happens to them when they do?" (PDF). Why Mormons Question.